Should you fix your old website or build a new one?
Fix it if the site is fast, works well on phones, runs on a platform you can edit and mainly needs better pages and search work. Rebuild it if it's slow, breaks on phones, runs on something nobody updates, or would need most pages rewritten anyway. Here's how to tell, and what each path costs.
Signs the site is worth fixing
- It loads quickly on a phone
- You, or someone you trust, can edit it
- The design still looks like your business today
- It shows up when people search your business name
- The problems are mostly missing pages, thin text or listings
Signs it's time to rebuild
- It's slow on phones, even after the images are compressed
- It runs on an old platform or plugins nobody updates
- You can't change anything without the person who built it
- Most pages would need rewriting anyway
- It looks older than your business is
Five checks you can do today
- The phone test
- Open the site on your phone, on mobile data rather than Wi-Fi. If the first screen takes more than a few seconds, many visitors won't wait.
- Search your service
- Search for your service and your town. If you're not on page one, look at who is, and how their pages differ from yours.
- Search your name
- If your own business name doesn't bring up your site and your Business Profile, something basic is wrong.
- Search Console
- If you have it, open the Pages report. A lot of pages marked "not indexed" points to a technical problem.
- Change a price
- Try updating a price or a phone number. If you can't, or it needs a developer, that cost comes back every time.
What each path costs with us
| Fix your current site | New site on a monthly plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $349 (Search & AI Visibility Plan) | Launch + Boost $278; Business + Boost $368 |
| What you get | Your site, improved every week | A new custom site, hosting, updates and search work |
| Setup fee | None | None |
These are our prices; another studio's will differ.
How we decide it with you
If you come to us for the Search & AI Visibility Plan, the first-month review answers this question for your site. If a rebuild would serve you better, we'll say so.
Common questions
Can I keep my domain if I rebuild?
Yes. The domain stays yours, and we redirect the old page addresses to the new ones, so Google doesn't lose what it already knows.
Will a new site lose my rankings?
Not if the move is done properly: pages at least as good as before, and every old address redirected. A common cause of lost rankings after a rebuild is old addresses that weren't redirected.
Can you rebuild in stages?
Sometimes: a new home page and service pages first, then the rest. It depends on the old platform.
Sources
Your site could be next on screen.
See your prices, pick a package, and send us a request.